There are so many standard gifts on a baby registry that we see all the time. Yes, they’re useful and parents need certain things like a car seat, diaper bag or baby mattress, but how great would it be if you could make a statement with a one-of-a-kind baby gift (that’s also useful!). Luckily, Etsy is the perfect place and a one-stop-shop for the most memorable newborn presents. We’ve come up with the ultimate baby gift guide and rounded up the top 25 baby shower gifts on Etsy, and they’re all under $100! Show your baby-having friends you care by shopping for these custom and creative gifts. Save your money on the typical expensive baby shower gifts and get a newborn one of these awesome Etsy finds. Here at Parade.com, we’re all about sharing products we love with our audience. When you make a purchase on an item seen on this page, we may earn a commission, however all picks are independently chosen unless otherwise mentioned.
25 Unique Baby Shower Gifts from Etsy
1. Baby Ribbed Headband, $7.24
The cutest bows for a baby girl. These handmade headbands come in six different colors so mom can match any outfit. “They even come out of the wash looking as perfect as new,” one customer shares. “I was worried it might lose its shape but it’s perfect!”
2. Personalized Name Puzzle With Pegs. $3.39
Give the parent-to-be a custom puzzle of the baby’s name. This playful gift is not only a fun activity for mom and dad to spend time together with their little one, it’s also effective so the child can easily learn his/her name.
Our Favorite Stroller
MINU® by UPPAbaby® Stroller in Jake
When you make a purchase on an item seen on this page, we may earn a commission, however, all picks are independently chosen unless otherwise mentioned.
Our Favorite Car Seat
Chicco® KeyFit® 30 Infant Car Seat in Orion
When you make a purchase on an item seen on this page, we may earn a commission, however, all picks are independently chosen unless otherwise mentioned.
A Diaper Bag With Style
Freshly Picked Diaper Bag in Ebony
When you make a purchase on an item seen on this page, we may earn a commission, however, all picks are independently chosen unless otherwise mentioned.
Our Favorite Humidifier For Your Little One
Fridababy® 3-in-1 Humidifier with Diffuser and Nightlight
When you make a purchase on an item seen on this page, we may earn a commission, however, all picks are independently chosen unless otherwise mentioned.
Our Favorite Baby Monitor
Nanit Pro™ Smart Baby Monitor & Wall Mount in White
When you make a purchase on an item seen on this page, we may earn a commission, however, all picks are independently chosen unless otherwise mentioned.
Our Favorite Baby Valentine’s Day Gifts
carter’s® Size 6M 2-Piece Valentine’s Day Bodysuit and Pant Set in Red
When you make a purchase on an item seen on this page, we may earn a commission, however, all picks are independently chosen unless otherwise mentioned.
3. 3in1 Cuddly Farm Sheep Folding Baby Blanket Crochet Pattern, $4.78
Introducing the best baby shower gift for your family member or friend — a warm blanket, a toy and bonuses as a decorative piece! This adorable crochet patterned lamb is a great addition to a baby’s nursery… and it’s so soft.
4. Gift for Mother of New Baby Gift Box Set, $45.00
All eyes will be on the newborn, so show an expecting mom some love with a luxury spa gift box. This handmade box includes a sentimental note that will touch her heart. It also serves as a beautiful keepsake and will be a nice reminder of how special she is.
5. Wrist Rattle & Foot Finder Socks, $10.75
Gift these sweet little wrist rattle and socks at the next baby shower you attend. These are made of a comfortable cotton/polyester blend and come in bright, contrasting patterns of spots and stripes making it easier for them to see and focus on. They’ll totally entertain the little one on the next long car ride, so momma will be happy!
6. Cute Hippo Pot with Mini Plant Animal Planter, $20.00
Make a statement at the baby shower with this hippo succulent for $20.00. It’s literally so cute, we want to buy one for ourselves!
7. Crochet Baby Shoes, Crochet Sneakers Inspired by Yeez Zebra, $33.58
For the trendy parents, buy these Yeezy-inspired crochet booties for the baby. They look exactly like the real ones, except they’re way cuter!
8. Moses Basket Changing Basket, $74.63
This handmade woven baby basket is lightweight so it’s super handy to have around! Its secure with high walls and makes it convenient for changing or napping. Purchase this high-quality baby basket for the little one in your life.
9. MINI Wooden Nursery Hanging Gift, $10.96
A new baby gift for the nursery! The base has the most precious little message written on it: “Twinkle Twinkle Little Star Do You Know How Loved You Are.” An Esty Reviewer says “the neutral colours would go with any nursery theme.”
10. Personalized Baby Rattle - Silver, $27.95
This is one of our favorite Etsy monogrammed baby gift ideas. With over 15k sales, the elegant silver plated baby rattle is a top-seller on Etsy! Engrave this special toy with a name, date or initials so the parents can add this to their baby’s keepsake box one day.
11. Safari Animals Baby Clothes Dividers, $8.77
We all know an organized mom. These darling dividers are have baby safari animals printed on them and give her the ability categorize her baby’s clothes into months. The bow detail is a nice decorative touch, too.
12. Blue Onesie Cupcakes - Baby Boy Gift, $37.95
At first, we literally had to do a double-take. This 3-pack of baby boy onesies are packaged and wrapped just like cupcakes! What a creative baby gift idea for soon-to-be parents. This present will also look so fun on display at a baby shower party!
13. Baby Shower Gift, Spiral Notebook, Guest Book, $14.99
Every new mom could use some words of advice and inspiration. Give a future mom a personalized spiral notebook so guests can leave notes and wishes for the baby. This is a sentimental gift she can always cherish and look back on as the baby grows older.
14. LumiPets LED Nightlight, $21.99
Here’s a bear nursery nightlight that has three different modes and nine vibrant colors. This polar bear light is eco-friendly and made of a non-toxic soft, washable, silicone-safe material that’s for babies and toddlers.
15. Baby Girls Posh Bodysuit, $58.99
Go ahead and spoil the newborn baby girl in your life with these fashion logo inspired baby onesies sets! You get these three Chanel, Louis Vuitton and Gucci onesie dupes for $58.99, and mom doesn’t have to worry about baby food getting on them!
16. Personalized Baby Quilt, $29.99
Etsy is known for custom monogramming gift options and this luxury quilt takes the cake for personalized baby shower gifts. It’s 100% cotton and has a gorgeous stitching pattern, making it a fabulous addition to the crib.
17. Baby Monthly Milestone Blocks, $29.87
We’ve all seen these in baby Instagram photoshoots. These Baby Monthly Milestone Blocks have become viral and are basically essential for the modern mom!
18. Diapertainment Give the gift of SANITY! | Entertain Baby While Diapering, $19.99
This is not your everyday phone holder — it’s so much more! You’ll be a life-saver by getting the “gift of sanity” Diapertainment on Etsy for an expecting mom. She can clip her phone in and stream baby shows on YouTube or photo slideshows to make diapering easier, faster, and less fussy!
19. Personalized Baby Gift, Baby Animal Lovey Blanket, Soother Blanket, $23.00
We all had that special security blanket or stuffed animal growing up. Be the special one in a newborn’s life to gift the personalized animal soother blanket. It’s a toy and mini blanket in one!
20. Organic Hooded Baby Towel Plus Washcloth, $19.99
It’s bath time! Utra soft and super absorbent the toddler hooded bath towel has a cute face design on the hood and will keep the baby warm after bathing.
21. Teething Toy, $8.79
Add a teething toy as a bonus gift to your baby shower gift. It’s under $10 and has raving reviews by Etsy customers. This is “genuinely the best teething toy I’ve purchased,” a reviewer says. “Perfect size and shape!”
22. Wood Camera Toy, $33.07
If you don’t know the gender of the baby before the baby shower, check out this vintage style mini wooden camera. It’s a classic toy that will last a lifetime. The parents can also put it on display on a shelf in the baby’s nursery.
23. Personalized Script Name Silicone Bib, $14.99
Just like the description says, “these bibs are the perfect gift and are sure to be a hit with ANY parent.” Dishwasher safe, easy to wipe down, and very functional, the silicone bib is a winner. You can also personalize the baby’s name is script front and center.
24. Organic Baby Duo, Organic Baby Balm and Organic Baby Bath, $18.17
You can get the new baby a great bath experience with this gift set of organic baby bath and matching baby balm. They’re made from organic Olive and Coconut Oils and Essential Oils, so they’re gentle enough for use even on a newborn.
25. Black & Gold Custom Pacifier with Personalized baby’s name Gift set with Clip, $29.95
To wrap up our Etsy Baby Shower Gift Guide, we’re leaving you with a boujee binky! The top of the line pacifier comes in a chic gold along with a clip, both customizable so you can write anything you want. If you’re expecting, check out 66+ baby freebies and discounts!
